Ankita Bhandari case: Disclosure of private chats triggers fresh political storm ahead of polls
Ankita Bhandari case: Disclosure of private chats triggers fresh political storm ahead of polls
S.M.A. KAZMI
Dehradun, Nov 18
The public disclosure of private chats between Ankita Bhandari and her male friend by Vinod Arya, father of Pulkit Arya, the prime accused in her murder case, has triggered a fresh controversy, raising serious legal and moral questions. The development has once again brought the sensational murder case into the political spotlight, triggering a war of words between the ruling BJP and opposition parties, besides drawing sharp reactions from social and civil society organisations, ahead of the crucial Uttarakhand Assembly elections.
On November 16, Vinod Arya, a former RSS-BJP leader who was expelled from the party following his son’s involvement in the crime, along with his lawyer, made public more than 4,000 pages of alleged chats on social media. He claimed that Ankita had been “harassed” by her parents and male friend and demanded that the conversations be made part of the investigation. He also alleged that his son had been falsely implicated under “political pressure” and claimed that Ankita had not been murdered but had died by suicide following harassment by her parents and friend. The disclosure came a day after Vinod Arya held a press conference in which he reiterated these allegations, seeking to challenge the prosecution’s case against his son.
Navneesh Negi, a lawyer of Ankita Bhandari said that it was immoral on the part of counsel of the and father of the accused to attempt to character assassinate the deceased. “The chats which were part of the case dairy were not relied upon by the prosecution and also found irrelevant to the murder case by the trial court as well as the High court sentencing the accused to life imprisonment. They are questioning the judgement and wisdom of the court. It is clear case of contempt of court and we plan to move an application in this regard,” he said.
Ankita Bhandari, a 19-year-old woman, was brutally murdered after she allegedly refused to provide “special services” to a VIP guest at the tourist resort where she worked. The resort owner, Pulkit Arya, and his two accomplices were arrested, charged with her murder and subsequently sentenced to life imprisonment by a court. All three are presently lodged in jail.
The case, however, returned to the headlines when Urmila Sanawar, who claimed to be the second wife of former BJP legislator Suresh Rathore, released an audio recording purportedly featuring the legislator identifying a person called ‘Gattu’ as the VIP who was expected to visit the ‘Vantara’ resort where Ankita worked.
Dushyant Gautam, BJP national general secretary and party in-charge for Uttarakhand, is allegedly known as ‘Gattu’ in political circles. The audio recording triggered widespread outrage across Uttarakhand, with demands for a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe into the alleged role of the VIP under the supervision of a sitting Supreme Court judge.
Amid mounting public pressure, Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami recommended a CBI investigation into the alleged VIP’s role in January this year. However, the investigation has made little visible progress so far.
The case again attracted national attention last month when Dushyant Gautam was appointed Governor of Sikkim. Ankita’s parents staged a protest at India Gate in New Delhi, alleging that Gautam’s appointment was intended to provide him with legal immunity in connection with the case. They were joined by Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi.
Subsequently, Pauri Garhwal MP Anil Baluni took Ankita’s parents to the CBI office and assured them that the investigation would be expedited.
Meanwhile, Urmila Sanawar, who had levelled allegations against Gautam and reportedly agreed to undergo a narco-analysis test as part of the CBI investigation, was arrested by Uttarakhand Police following a complaint lodged by the daughter of Suresh Rathore. She was subsequently sent to jail. After securing bail, Sanawar agreed to undergo a narco-analysis test before a CBI court. The test is expected to be conducted at Gandhinagar in Gujarat in the near future.
With the demand for justice by Ankita’s parents increasingly emerging as a potential election issue, the latest disclosure of her private conversations has further inflamed public sentiment and intensified the political confrontation between the BJP and opposition parties.
Adding fuel to the controversy, Dilip Rawat, a three-time BJP MLA from Lansdowne in Pauri Garhwal district, asked Ankita’s parents to return the compensation received from the state government if they were dissatisfied with the investigation. His remarks have drawn sharp criticism and further aggravated the controversy.
The opposition has termed the disclosure of Ankita’s private conversations immoral, describing it as an attempt to assassinate her character even after her physical murder. Members of the Mahila Congress staged a protest outside Vinod Arya’s residence in Haridwar, demanding action against him.
Ankita’s parents have also demanded legal action against Vinod Arya, accusing him of attempting to mislead the investigation. They have further demanded that he undergo a narco-analysis test. The Pahadi Samaj, a social organisation, has also lodged a complaint against him with the Haridwar police.
Senior Congress leader Harak Singh Rawat described the disclosure as a crude and insensitive attempt by the ruling BJP establishment to malign Ankita’s character, nearly four years after her murder. Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami, meanwhile, accused the Congress of exploiting the Ankita Bhandari murder case for political purposes.
Reacting to the controversy, Suryakant Dhasmana, vice-president of the Uttarakhand Congress, alleged that the disclosure of a deceased young woman’s private conversations was part of an attempt by the ruling establishment to confuse the public ahead of the Assembly elections. “It is morally reprehensible,” he said.



